GUITARRONS | NECK RESETS | DISSONANCE DELIGHT

Send Us a Question

Guitarróns

Rene Benavidez plays a guitarrón.
Photo courtesy of the International Folk Culture Center

Q I am a double bass player, and I need to find a guitarrón for a special project. Could you give me some background on guitarróns and some advice about where to purchase one?

Steve Arie
Sydney, Australia

A The guitarrón is the large bass guitar–like instrument that provides the bouncy groove at the heart of most mariachi bands. The development of the guitarrón is commonly attributed to the Cocas people of Jalisco, Mexico, who adapted European stringed instruments for their own hybrid music. In earlier times a gut-string harp would have provided the low end in a traditional string ensemble, but since the advent of the guitarrón in the 18th century, its portability and volume have made it more popular for standing and strolling than the unwieldy harp.

With its short, fretless fingerboard; broad top; and deep, protruding back, the guitarrón resembles a standard six-string on steroids. The traditional tuning is A D G C E A, with the lowest string an octave below the open-A fifth string of standard guitar tuning and the high A string a minor third below the C of the third string. Some modern players retune the instrument one octave below standard guitar tuning--E A D G B E.

The instrument is used to play bass lines that parallel chord progressions, typically with two strings plucked simultaneously in octaves. The guitarrón tuning facilitates the unique percussive style. The high action and stiff tension usually found on a guitarrón require great strength and dexterity. It is not an instrument for the faint-hearted or casual player.

Most modern guitarróns are constructed with Mexican cedar backs and sides and a top made of tacota, a light wood sometimes compared to balsa. Construction on most traditional guitarróns is relatively simple, with few of the refinements associated with top-notch lutherie. As a result, the instruments are very affordable.

There are many sources for guitarróns within Mexico and several sources in the U.S. The Mariachi Connection (www.mariachiconnection.com) offers several models ranging from $600 to $800. You can also purchase a guitarrón from Lark in the Morning’s online music shop at www.larkinam.com. The company offers a standard model for $500 and often has one-off instruments of higher quality. Traditional guitarróns are often fitted with wooden friction-style tuning pegs, but the geared machines found on some instruments are much easier to use for the novice.

While the guitarrón is the proper instrument for traditional mariachi and similar conjunto musics, guitarists and bassists wishing to add a low acoustic ax to their arsenal should consider picking up the acoustic bass guitar. Many musicians find these easier to play and more versatile than the guitarrón, and their standard guitar tuning makes them a snap to play. There are excellent fretted and fretless instruments made by Epiphone, Martin, and many other manufacturers. These acoustic basses generally need a little additional amplification, but even a small battery-powered mini-amp does the job for most occasions.

––Paul Kotapish

Return to Top

Neck Resets

Q If I change the neck angle on my 1986 Tony Rice Santa Cruz dreadnought (to make it more playable), will it maintain its sonic quality and value?

Henry Emery
Tucson, Arizona

A Resetting the neck in order to lower the guitar’s action is preferable to shaving the bridge too low. While some guitars have bridges thick enough to withstand being lowered several times, the guitar top needs a certain amount of stress and torque to sound right. How much is right? Tough call long distance. I’d get a qualified luthier to look at it. With a good neck reset, you get the best of both worlds--proper neck-to-body geometry and the great tone of nice, aged topwood.

––Rick Turner

Return to Top

Dissonance Delight

Q I'm trying to learn a new song, and the dissonance between some of the melody notes and the guitar parts is driving me nuts. Is there some mistake in the notation?

—Ellis Carmine
Jacksonville, Florida

A Dissonance can be described as notes whose frequencies are less than harmonious to our ears. For instance, playing notes that are a half step apart (the open E string of your guitar, for example, played with a D# achieved by fretting the second string at the fourth fret) is considered dissonant by most people. Dissonance is an essential part of most music; it provides "tension" that leads to "release." When you slowly practice a new piece, you hear intervals (two notes) and chords (three or more notes) out of context, which emphasizes the dissonance. When you play the piece at performance speed, it's much less noticeable. If the composer or arranger did his or her job, the dissonant interval or chord will sound fine within the context of the moving music. Dissonance is also in the ear of the beholder and is in part a cultural phenomenon. People are conditioned by sounds around them as they develop their musical ears. A half-step interval may be beautiful to one listener and unbearable to another. In modern pop music of the Crosby, Stills, and Nash variety, the harmony voices usually sing lines that parallel the melody and create continuously harmonious chords. In other music, such as the choral pieces of 500 years ago, each voice has its own melodic shape and does not necessarily parallel any of the others. This can lead to some chordal dissonance, but that dissonance is wonderful-it's exactly the right thing for that moment in the music. Opening your ears to sounds from different cultures and different eras can be an educational and rewarding undertaking. If you are interested in hearing how composers use dissonance, buy a CD of Renaissance choral music by Carlo Gesualdo.

—Mark Hanson

 

SEND QUESTIONS, tips, or observations to Acoustic Guitar’s online discussion forums at www.acousticguitar.com or write to Dear A.G., Acoustic Guitar, PO Box 767, San Anselmo, CA 94979-0767.

Excerpted from Acoustic Guitar magazine, January 2001, No. 97.

SEND QUESTIONS TO Dear A.G., Acoustic Guitar, PO Box 767, San Anselmo, CA 94979-0767; or go to our online form. Get answers to your questions online at the Guitar Talk discussion forums. There are sections for chatting about gear and guitars (Gear), players and recordings (Players), and technique and theory (Playing Guitar).

 


 Return to Top