Updating an old guitar



B. J. Combs

Updating an old guitar

This may sound dumb, but I have an old Gibson Southern Jumbo almost 50 years old. It still has the original tuning pegs on it which are very hard to turn. I've been thinking about replacing them with a set of Grover tuning pegs. But I am worried about it affecting the value of the guitar. Also I am not sure exactly what tuning pegs (ratio wise) would be good if I decide to change them out. Does anyone out there have any thoughts about this? Any feedback is appreciated. Thanks!


Posted 8 months ago by B. J. Combs - 7 replies

Newest replies displayed first - click to reverse
Gary Toth

"Get some new tuning machines that work properly and fit the existing footprint of the originals and put the originals (and all their associated hardware) in a ziploc bag and keep them in a safe place just in case you ever decide to sell the guitar... at which point you can either reinstall them or simply include them in the sale of the guitar. By doing it this way, you will not hurt the value of your guitar in the least, since the original machines are still a viable option for the new owner to use."

Yup, this is the way to fly. You can have your cake and eat it, too.... so to speak. :)


Reply posted 2 weeks ago by Gary Toth


Jeremy Taylor

original is always worth more
http://jtay.me


Reply posted 1 month ago by Jeremy Taylor


brent crozier

Hey BJ,

I have a 40 year old SJ. Great guitar made even better when I replaced the Klue-Less tuners with Grovers 20 years ago. I put the silver plated klu's on my 69 ES330. And put the Plastic tuners from that on an ancient Silvertone acoustic.
Anyway, The purist collectors may balk at the non-original tuners but you will appreciate the improvement in tuning


Reply posted 2 months ago by brent crozier


brent crozier

Hey BJ,

I have a 40 year old SJ. Great guitar made even better when I replaced the Klue-Less tuners with Grovers 20 years ago. I put the silver plated klu's on my 69 ES330. And put the Plastic tuners from that on an ancient Silvertone acoustic.
Anyway, The purist collectors may balk at the non-original tuners but you will appreciate the improvement in tuning


Reply posted 2 months ago by brent crozier



Login or register to join the discussion
Get all things acoustic guitar in your inbox with our free newsletters. Your E-mail: